Grilled Cheese Gallery

Ordering Options

Call to order at (312)285-2202

Always Available

The Classic $7.00*
Prairie Pure Butterkäse Cheese, Bennison's Bakery Fresh Baked White Sourdough Bread,

and Nordic Creamery Fresh Butter.
*$9.00 w/ bacon
*$10.00 w/ ham

On The Lighter Side $10.00
Small Classic Grilled Cheese, small cup of Tomato Pesto Soup* and potato chips.
*Contains pine nuts

The Duke $11.00
Prairie Pure Swiss Cheese, Jake's Ham and your choice of toppings:

* Duke's Alehouse Beer Mustard

* Poblano Mustard from Coop Sauce

* Blueberry Mustard and Fresh Peach slices (available July only)
* Cranberry Mustard

Rhubarb Mustard

The Breakfast Club - $13.00

Choose your sandwich

​1. Double Prairie Pure Butterkäse Cheese, Farm Fresh Egg, Jake's Pork Sausage and Pure Maple Syrup


2. Double Prairie Pure Swiss Cheese, Farm Fresh Egg, TJ's Free Range Poultry Turkey Sausage, Fresh Mushrooms and Smoked Onion Marmalade from Southport Grocery

3. Double Prairie Pure White Cheddar Cheese, Farm Fresh Eggs, Pure Maple Syrup and Jake's Country Meats' Bacon

The Little Italy $10.00*
Prairie Pure Butterkäse Cheese, Five Cheese Garlic Spread, River Valley Heirloom Tomato Salsa and Underground Meats Pepperoni.
*$9.00 - No Pepperoni

The Southport $8.00
Prairie Pure Butterkäse Cheese and Smoked Onion Marmalade from Southport Grocery and Café.

The Blue Buffalo - $13.00
Prairie Pure Butterkäse Cheese House made Buffalo Chicken and Prairie Pure Blue Cheese

The Pulled Porker - $14.00

Prairie Pure Butterkäse Cheese, House made BBQ pulled pork using Broad Shoulders BBQ sauce

*Optional slaw (diced carrots and honey crisp apples)

The River Valley $9.00
Prairie Pure Swiss Cheese, Fresh Sautéed Mushrooms, Smoked Onion Marmalade.

The Sweetie Pie $10.00
Prairie Pure Swiss Cheese, Bushel & Peck's Fresh Raspberry Jam and Three Sisters Garden roasted pecans.

The Sebastian*$16.00
Double Prairie Pure Butterkäse Cheese and Fresh Lobster.
*Fridays Only!




The Abreo $10.00
Prairie Pure White Cheddar Cheese, honey crisp apples from Mick Klug Farm St. Joseph, MI, Bacon Onion Jam from Abreo Restaurant Rockford, IL.

The Jake $12.00
Prairie Pure Gouda Cheese, Jake's Ham, and apple butter.

The Margarita $9.00
Prairie Pure Butterkäse Cheese, basil pesto (no pine nuts), and fresh tomato.

Breakfast Club #4 - $13.00

Double Prairie Pure White Cheddar Cheese, Farm Fresh Eggs, Chorizo, Hot Sauce, Fresh Cilantro and Jalapeño (option)

*Available July - October



FREE Add-Ons*

Fresh greens: spinach, arugula, cilantro, jalapenos

*When available

Add Protein
Ham +$3.00
Bacon +$2.00
Pork Sausage +$2.00
Turkey Sausage +$2.00

Farm Fresh Egg +$1.00

Add Extra Cheese

Prairie Pure Feta +$1.00

Tomato Basil Feta +$1.00

Blue cheese +$1.00

Swiss cheese +$1.00

Gouda cheese +$1.00

White Cheddar cheese +$1.00

Butterkäse +$1.00

Seasonal Add-Ons
Tomato +$1.00

Gluten Free Pita (My Bread®) +$3.00


Tomato Pesto Soup*

Mighty Vine tomatoes, house made pesto (in season), organic pesto (off season), local onion, kosher salt & pepper

*Contains Pine Nuts

Sizes:   Cup $5       Bowl $8     Lil' Dipper $2.50

Deep Fried Cheese Curds*

*Available at the storefront the last week of the farmers markets and the last Saturday Green City outdoor market.

House Made Mac-n-Cheese
Sizes:    Regular $6.00     Little Mac $3.00

Add ons:

Garlic toast for $1.00 more
NEW pulled pork for $3.00 more
Bacon Bits for $2.00 more
Smoked Onion Marmalade for $1.00 more

Fridays Only! Add Lobster for $8.00 more

Housemade potato chips - $2.00



$2.50 each or 2 for $4.00

Locally made cookies with a variety of flavors
Triple Chip | Oreo, Buckeye | PB&J | Sugar Sprinkle | Lemon | Chocolate Carmel pretzel | Chocolate Salted Carmel | M&M | Snickerdoodle | Oatmeal butterscotch | and more!



Aluminum can


Ginger Beer

Hot/Iced Tea
SenTEAmental Moods

Hot Chocolate
with locally made marshmallows

Filbert's Soda
based in Chicago – variety of flavors
Cola | Cherry Cola | Diet Cola | Root Beer | Diet Root Beer | Cream Soda | Orange | Blue Raspberry | Green Apple | Ginger Ale | Lemonade | Pink Lemonade | Strawberry | Black Cherry | Sparkling Water | Lemon Sparkling Water | Pomegranate Sparkling Water



Smoked Onion Marmalade

Good Food Award Winner

Smoked organic sweet & red onions, sparrow apple cider vinegar, brown cane sugar, sparrow white balsamic vinegar, local honey & kosher salt


Apple Butter

Local apples, brown cane sugar, local apple cider, sparrow apple cider vinegar, cinnamon, nutmeg, Nielsen Massey vanilla & kosher salt

Rhubarb Mustard

Local rhubarb, organic cane sugar, champagne vinegar, yellow mustard seeds, organic local red onion, red wine vinegar & kosher salt

Blueberry Mustard

Local blueberries, organic cane sugar, white wine vinegar, yellow mustard seed, white wine, sparrow white balsamic vinegar, lemon, local ginger & kosher salt

Cranberry Mustard

Local cranberries, organic cane sugar, yellow mustard seed, white wine vinegar, local maple syrup, rose wine, spices & kosher salt

Our House Made Pesto

Fresh local basil, lemon juice, parmesan cheese, olive oil, salt, pepper & garlic. NO NUTS


Download Our

Mobile Delivery App

Gayle V’s Best Ever Grilled Cheese

108 N State St, Suite 27 | Chicago, IL 60602 | (312) 285-2202 |

  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Copyright © 2021 Gayle V's Best Ever Grilled Cheese | All rights reserved | Designed by KT, PE, JM

The Breakfast Club